Situation: My opponent was breaking 8-ball and hit the 3rd row. Is this a foul or an illegal break?
It is an illegal break. The cue ball must make contact with the rack as follows to be considered legal:
8-Ball - The head ball or the second row of balls must be struck first. Failure to strike the head ball or second row of balls does not result in a foul.
If the rack is struck, but the break does not qualify as legal, the balls are reracked by the non-breaking player and rebroken by the same breaking player.
If the rack is struck, but the break does not qualify as legal and results in a scratch, the balls are reracked and broken by the opposite player.
Rule: Official Team Manual (OTM) page 45-46 section 3 “Breaking”: https://media.poolplayers.com/TMRB/Team-Manual-English.pdf
This section also covers:
- Same scenario but for 9-ball.
- Players physically unable to break and what happens.
- Where the cue ball needs to be to break.
- Legal and non-legal breaks.
- When the break switches to your opponent.
- Where the rack must be struck.
- Soft breaking.
You can submit a "Rule of the Week" to the league office:
- Email to sandiego@apaleagues.com.
- Email Subject Line must read “SDAPA Rule of the Week”
- Clearly state the rule/situation and if you know where the answer is found please provide those details.
